During a press conference in São Paulo, the Minister of the Environment openly questioned the efficacy of Fundo Amazônia, the collective fund that concentrates donations from Norway, Germany and Petrobras. The fund is managed by BNDES and has invested over R$ 1.8 billion for projects aiming to reduce deforestation. Minister Salles rejected reports from Fundo Amazônia indicating that it helped to reduce Amazon deforestation by 11% between 2009 and 2017, saying that such relationship of cause and effect has yet to be proven. Fundo Amazônia reports uses deforestation data from INPE’s monitoring of the region. Minister Salles went on to say that a quarter of the contracts of Fundo Amazônia need to be “rigorously analysed” by controlling bodies (BNDES, CGU and TCU) due to “evidence of dysfunctionalities”. Most of Fundo Amazônia projects involve NGOs and other civil society entities. By raising these suspicions, the minister dismissed the findings of a parliamentary inquiry carried in 2018 that found the overall management of the fund to be “satisfactory” and the positive results of 2 yearly independent audits carried on the fund’s activities. Salles also created a stir by suggesting to use money from the fund to compensate private landowners located inside conservation units and protected areas.
A few hours after the interview, the Embassy of Norway, the Fundo Amazônia’s biggest donor, published a note declaring to be “satisfied with the robust governance structure of Fundo Amazônia” and the significant results achieved by entities supported by the fund in the last 10 years. “We have not received any proposal from Brazilian authorities to alter the governance structure or the criteria used by the Fund to allocate resources”.
Sources: